Gourmet Time Travel: Exploring South Central Wisconsin's Oldest Culinary Gems

Embark with friends and family on a gourmet journey through south central Wisconsin's oldest restaurants, where the past comes alive through exceptional dishes and captivating stories. From revived traditional recipes to historic landmarks that have become culinary institutions, join us as we travel through time, savoring the flavors and experiencing the nostalgia that these venerable dining establishments offer. 

Toby's Supper Club – Madison

Our first stop on this culinary adventure is a local Madison gem that has stood the test of time. Since 1937, Toby's Supper Club has been delighting diners with its rustic supper club experience. The casual atmosphere, friendly bartenders and Key Lime Pie Martini set the stage for an unforgettable dining experience best enjoyed with good company.

Visitors can savor their famous Friday fish fry or indulge in a perfectly cooked steak, accompanied by timeless sides like creamy mashed potatoes and steamed veggies. Toby's offers a taste of nostalgia that will transport you and your crew back to the early post-prohibition era of supper clubs.

Quivey's Grove – Fitchburg

Continuing our journey, we arrive at Quivey's Grove, a historic restaurant nestled in Fitchburg near Wisconsin’s capital city. Housed in a collection of carefully restored buildings from the 1850s, Quivey's Grove offers two delightful dining experiences that both pay homage to the region's agricultural heritage with dishes made from locally sourced ingredients. Feast on farm-to-table creations like roasted duck breast or Wisconsin cheese platters while surrounded by the charm of the past.

The first is the elegant Stone House, where you and your group can indulge in a refined culinary journey. Stepping inside the Stone House, you'll be greeted by a warm atmosphere and genuine antiques. The beautifully restored interior showcases a blend of rustic elements and sophisticated touches, creating an atmosphere that is perfect for celebrating special occasions or savoring a romantic dinner.

For those seeking a more relaxed and casual setting, the Stable Grill is the spot for you. Located in a renovated barn setting, the Stable Grill exudes a laid-back charm that instantly puts you at ease. As you enter, you'll be captivated by the rustic decor, featuring tasteful memorabilia that harken back to a bygone era. The ambiance is cozy and inviting, creating an ideal space for gathering with friends and family.

One of the highlights of Quivey's Grove is its enchanting walkable gardens. Stroll along the meandering pathways surrounded by vibrant blooms and lush greenery and immerse yourself in the tranquility of nature. The gardens provide an idyllic setting for a leisurely post-meal stroll, allowing you to savor the beauty of the surroundings and quality time with loved ones.

Delaney's – Madison

Located on Madison's west side, Delaney's is an iconic family-owned steakhouse that has been a favorite of locals since 1973. From the classic bread baskets to the friendly staff and the enticing aroma of sizzling steaks, when you step into this restaurant with your group you’ll know you’re about to have a great experience.

The Delaney’s team is famous for serving high-quality, hand-cut steaks, prepared to perfection and served on sizzling cast-iron plates. Whether you prefer a tender filet mignon or a juicy ribeye, paired with classic sides like loaded baked potatoes or steamed asparagus, Delaney's offers a timeless dining experience you and your whole family can enjoy together. A hot tip for visitors: start with their legendary onion rings.

Dorf Haus Supper Club – Roxbury

Step into the Dorf Haus in Roxbury to be transported to a world of old-world charm. This family-owned restaurant embraces its German heritage and delights in serving traditional cuisine that has been cherished for generations. The cozy wood-paneled interiors and rustic atmosphere create an inviting space where you can gather with your favorite people.

Savor the flavors of hearty German favorites like schnitzel, sauerbraten and bratwurst, alongside delectable American dishes. And as you indulge in the delicious food, immerse yourself in the authentic ambiance by listening to lively polka music that fills the air. The cheerful melodies will set the tone for merriment, as you tap your feet and maybe even take a twirl on the dance floor.

To enhance your experience, be sure to try their renowned Old Fashioned cocktails and join in the excitement of their Friday Night fish fry. As the laughter flows and stories are shared, the Dorf Haus becomes a place where memories are made. With its commitment to preserving traditions and warm hospitality, this treasured establishment invites you to create unforgettable moments with your loved ones, all while savoring the rich flavors of authentic German cuisine.

The Old Feed Mill – Mazomanie

Our final destination is a true hidden gem that showcases Wisconsin's rural history. Housed in a 19th-century mill, this restaurant in a small community just west of Madison offers a truly historic setting. The Old Feed Mill serves up comfort food with a twist, using locally sourced ingredients whenever possible. Stop in with loved ones to delight in their signature dishes like chicken pot pie or fork-tender pot roast made from scratch. Every visit to The Old Feed Mill is a journey back in time, celebrating the region's agricultural roots.

We hope you've enjoyed this culinary expedition through some of the region's oldest and most cherished restaurants. Each of these establishments has not only preserved the flavors of the past but also shared the stories and traditions that have shaped Wisconsin's culinary landscape. So, step into history, indulge in delectable dishes and make lasting memories in these culinary gems that have stood the test of time.

Searching for something to do after fueling up through this gourmet journey? Explore these fun outdoor activities to enjoy with friends and family in Madison.